Big tech reviews

Facebook Recommendations: A Social Graph Pretending to Be a Review System

Facebook used to have star ratings on Pages. It has since replaced them with Recommendations — a yes-or-no question and an optional comment. The result is a review-shaped feature attached to a social network, with all the strengths and weaknesses that implies.

Quick Verdict

Who it's for
Local businesses with active Facebook Pages; consumers who already use Facebook for local discovery.
Who pays
Businesses pay for Facebook ads; Recommendations themselves are free to give and receive.
What to watch
Recommendations are public, visible to friends, and tied to a social account that may not be a real customer.
Racket Score
2.0 / 5

What Facebook Recommendations actually does

On a business's Facebook Page, visitors can answer "Yes" or "No" to the question "Do you recommend [Business]?" and add an optional comment. Recommendations are public on the Page and may surface in friends' feeds. Pages display the proportion of positive recommendations rather than a star rating.

How businesses use Facebook Recommendations

The proposition is simple and free: claim the Page, post regularly, respond to recommendations. There is no paid review tier. Facebook ads are a separate product that can amplify the Page's reach but do not directly affect recommendation outcomes.

What you should understand before trusting it

  1. No proof of transaction is required. Anyone with a Facebook account can recommend or not.
  2. Visibility depends on the social graph. A friend's recommendation is amplified to your feed; a stranger's recommendation typically isn't.
  3. The metric is a proportion, not a score. "94% recommend" sounds different from "4.7 out of 5", but is structurally similar — and equally easy to skim past.
  4. Spam and fake accounts are a known problem. Facebook moderates them, with mixed and varying results.
“A recommendation from a friend is signal. A recommendation from a stranger on Facebook is content.”

The funny bit

Facebook Recommendations is the platform where you can find a glowing endorsement of a Brighton sandwich shop written by an account that joined Facebook last week, has three friends, all of whom are also accounts that joined Facebook last week, and whose profile picture is suspiciously similar to a stock photograph. It is also the platform where your auntie Linda, who has known the owner since 1987, will leave a recommendation that is genuinely the most useful sentence ever written about that sandwich shop. Both things live on the same Page.

The serious bit

Facebook Recommendations is most useful for local consumers who can read the recommender's profile and judge the source. It is least useful as a top-of-mind comparison tool for unfamiliar businesses. For UK consumers, treat it as supporting evidence rather than a primary source — particularly for businesses where higher-rigour platforms (Trustpilot, Google, Which? Trusted Traders) are also available.

Review Racket scorecard

  • Transparency2 / 5
  • Verification rigour2 / 5
  • Consumer usefulness2 / 5
  • Independence from paying parties2 / 5
  • Plain-English fine print2 / 5
  • Overall Racket Score2.0 / 5

Facebook Recommendations FAQs

Did Facebook used to have star ratings?

Yes. The system was changed to a yes-or-no Recommendations format.

Are Facebook Recommendations verified?

They are tied to a Facebook account but not to a transaction.

Can businesses remove negative recommendations?

Only when they break Facebook's community standards. Disputed recommendations can be reported, with mixed outcomes.

Do Facebook ads affect recommendation outcomes?

Ads can increase Page visibility and traffic. They do not directly change which recommendations appear or how they're ranked.

Is Facebook a strong primary review source for businesses?

For some local businesses, yes — particularly those with active community Pages. For most categories, it sits alongside higher-rigour platforms rather than replacing them.

Disclaimer. "Facebook" is a trademark of Meta Platforms, Inc. Used here for the purposes of identification, commentary and review only. Review Racket is independent and unaffiliated.