Travel & local

Yelp: The American Original and Its Famously Opinionated Filter

Yelp is the platform people in Britain mostly notice when they're abroad and it is the platform people in America argue about most loudly. Its recommendation algorithm — the famous "filter" — decides which reviews count toward a business's score, and that single design decision produces most of the conversation around it.

Quick Verdict

Who it's for
Local consumer decisions, particularly in food, retail and personal services; less central in the UK than in the US.
Who pays
Businesses pay for advertising, prominent placements and profile-enhancement features.
What to watch
"Recommended" vs "not recommended" reviews — the filter decides which counts.
Racket Score
2.6 / 5

What Yelp actually does

Yelp is an open-posting local business review platform. Reviewers create accounts, leave reviews, and over time build a public profile that the platform uses to weight their contributions. The recommendation software — Yelp's automated filter — decides which reviews are shown by default ("Recommended") and which are tucked behind an extra click ("Not currently recommended"). The score on a Yelp business page is calculated only from recommended reviews.

How businesses use Yelp

Yelp's commercial product is largely advertising: paid placements at the top of category and competitor pages, branded business profiles, custom call-to-action buttons. Yelp does not charge businesses to claim a profile or to receive reviews. It does charge for visibility and promotional features — and in the US, the relationship between advertising and visibility has been the subject of long-running public debate.

In the UK, Yelp is a smaller but still active player, particularly in London for restaurants, bars and personal services.

What you should understand before trusting it

  1. The filter is the story. A business's visible score reflects only "recommended" reviews. The "not currently recommended" reviews — sometimes a substantial proportion of the total — sit behind a separate link.
  2. Reviewer history matters more than on most platforms. Yelp weights reviews by the reviewer's track record on the platform.
  3. Advertising and ranking are separate, but adjacent. Yelp publishes that ad spend doesn't affect the score; it does affect placement on category pages.
  4. The platform is more US-shaped than UK-shaped. A category that's busy in San Francisco can be sparse in Manchester.
“On Yelp, the score is what the filter let through. The filter is the editor.”

The funny bit

Yelp is the only platform where a reviewer can describe a single bowl of ramen with the literary ambition of a Booker Prize entry, and then have the review hidden behind a button labelled "Not currently recommended" for reasons no human will ever explain. The platform has cultivated a particular type of reviewer — the Yelp Elite — and a particular type of sentence, which begins "I usually don't write reviews, but…" and continues for six paragraphs.

The serious bit

Yelp is genuinely useful in dense urban categories where the sample is large and the reviewer base is active. The reading habit that pays off is clicking through to "not currently recommended" — sometimes the filtered reviews are obvious one-off rants, but sometimes they are texture the headline score has flattened.

For UK readers, Yelp is most useful when researching London hospitality. For UK businesses, it is rarely the first platform to invest in, but it should be claimed and monitored.

Review Racket scorecard

  • Transparency3 / 5
  • Verification rigour2 / 5
  • Consumer usefulness3 / 5
  • Independence from paying parties3 / 5
  • Plain-English fine print2 / 5
  • Overall Racket Score2.6 / 5

Yelp FAQs

Why are some Yelp reviews hidden as "not recommended"?

Yelp's automated software flags reviews it judges less reliable — for example, from new accounts, or with unusual patterns — and excludes them from the calculated score. The reviews remain visible, but require an extra click.

Can businesses pay to influence their Yelp score?

Yelp publishes that advertising does not change the score. Advertising can change where a business appears in category and search results.

Is Yelp big in the UK?

Smaller than in the US, but active — particularly in London hospitality.

How are Yelp Elite reviewers chosen?

Yelp Elite is a community programme recognising active, high-quality reviewers based on volume, content quality and platform engagement.

Can businesses respond to Yelp reviews?

Yes, both publicly and privately, through Yelp for Business.

Disclaimer. "Yelp" is a trademark of Yelp Inc. Used here for the purposes of identification, commentary and review only. Review Racket is independent and unaffiliated.